Being charged with possession of stolen property is a serious legal issue that can damage your record and your future. But here’s the truth—just because you were found with property that turned out to be stolen doesn’t automatically make you guilty. Understanding how to beat a possession of stolen property charge involves knowledge of the law, intent, and how prosecutors must prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
In this guide, we’ll explain what this charge means, what the prosecution must prove, and the most effective defenses you or your attorney can use.
—
What Is Possession of Stolen Property?
Possession of stolen property is a criminal charge that involves knowingly having, buying, receiving, or concealing property that was obtained unlawfully. Laws vary slightly by state, but the core idea remains: if you possess property that was stolen and knew or should have known it was stolen, you could face criminal charges.
This crime is often charged as either a misdemeanor or felony, depending on:
- The value of the stolen property
- Whether you have prior convictions
- If the possession was linked to other crimes
For example, possessing a stolen car is likely to result in felony charges, while unknowingly buying a stolen laptop might be treated as a misdemeanor.
—
What Prosecutors Must Prove
To secure a conviction, prosecutors must establish three main elements:
- The property was indeed stolen
- You were in possession of that property
- You knew, or reasonably should have known, that the property was stolen
Understanding this is the first step in learning how to beat a possession of stolen property charge—because if any of these points cannot be proven, you have grounds for a defense.
—
Common Defenses to Beat the Charge
Below are some of the most effective legal strategies to fight a possession of stolen property charge. Always consult with a qualified criminal defense attorney to apply the best option to your case.
1. Lack of Knowledge
One of the most common and strongest defenses is lack of knowledge. If you didn’t know—or had no reasonable way of knowing—that the item was stolen, you cannot be convicted.
Examples:
- Buying an item from an online marketplace without signs it was stolen
- Receiving a gift from someone you trusted
- Purchasing goods with a receipt or documentation
Prosecutors have to prove that you knew the item was stolen. If they can’t, the case may be dismissed.
🛈 Related Read: “Can a Creditor Take Property That Is Jointly Owned” — learn about legal ownership issues that can complicate possession cases.
2. Innocent Possession
You may have possessed the stolen item for a legitimate reason—such as returning it to its owner or turning it over to the police. This is often called “innocent possession.”
Make sure to document any communication or action that supports your intent to return the property.
3. No Possession
Sometimes, a person is accused simply because they were near stolen property or knew someone involved in a theft. But mere proximity is not the same as legal possession.
Proving you didn’t have control over or access to the item can serve as a solid defense.
4. Mistaken Identity
If you’ve been wrongfully accused, your attorney may argue mistaken identity. Surveillance footage, GPS tracking, or credible alibis can support your innocence.
🛈 Pro Tip: Check our guide “Where Can I Find a Land Survey of My Property” to understand evidence in civil property disputes—it may be helpful in proving ownership in court.
—
What If You Bought the Item?
Let’s say you purchased an item without realizing it was stolen. To convict you, prosecutors must prove you ignored obvious signs:
- A luxury watch sold for a fraction of its value
- A seller unwilling to provide a receipt or ID
- A transaction in a shady location (parking lot, alley, etc.)
If you can prove the deal appeared legitimate, your attorney may argue you acted in good faith.
—
What to Do If You’re Charged
If you’re facing a possession of stolen property charge, follow these steps:
- Don’t talk to police without an attorney present
- Gather any documents, receipts, or messages related to the item
- Identify and contact any witnesses who can support your version of events
- Hire a skilled criminal defense attorney
Never attempt to resolve the issue without legal representation. A single wrong statement can be used against you.
—
FAQs: Possession of Stolen Property Charges
🟢 Is possession of stolen property a felony?
It depends on the value of the item and state law. Typically, items valued over $1,000 are charged as felonies.
🟢 Can I go to jail for having stolen property?
Yes, especially if it’s a felony charge. Jail time can range from a few months to several years.
🟢 What if I return the stolen property?
Returning stolen property does not automatically erase the charge, but it may be viewed favorably during plea negotiations or sentencing.
🟢 How long does a possession charge stay on my record?
A conviction can stay on your record permanently unless expunged. Avoiding conviction is the best strategy.
—
Final Thoughts: How to Beat a Possession of Stolen Property Charge
Beating a possession of stolen property charge requires a well-planned defense, clear evidence, and an experienced attorney. Focus on whether you knew the item was stolen, whether you truly possessed it, and whether the prosecution can prove their case.
You have rights—and with the right legal guidance, you can defend them.
Need help understanding more about property and law? Check out:
- “Is Destruction of Property a Felony”
- “Property Line Dispute: Who Pays for Survey”
- “Can You Drink and Drive on Private Property”
